Wyden, Udall Question the Value and Efficacy of Phone Records Collection in Stopping Attacks

Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senators Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) and Mark Udall (D-Colo.) issued the following joint statement challenging claims that bulk phone record collection by the Intelligence Community has been “a critical tool in protecting the nation.” Wyden and Udall are members of the Senate Intelligence Committee.

“In our capacity as members of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, we have spent years examining the intelligence collection operations that have been secretly authorized under the USA Patriot Act.  Based on this experience, we respectfully but firmly disagree with the way that this program has been described by senior administration officials.

After years of review, we believe statements that this very broad Patriot Act collection has been “a critical tool in protecting the nation” do not appear to hold up under close scrutiny.  We remain unconvinced that the secret Patriot Act collection has actually provided any uniquely valuable intelligence.  As far as we can see, all of the useful information that it has provided appears to have also been available through other collection methods that do not violate the privacy of law-abiding Americans in the way that the Patriot Act collection does.  We hope that President Obama will probe the basis for these assertions, as we have.

We also disagree with the statement that the broad Patriot Act collection strikes the “right balance” between protecting American security and protecting Americans’ privacy.  In our view it does not.  When Americans call their friends and family, whom they call, when they call, and where they call from is private information. We believe the large-scale collection of this information by the government has a very significant impact on Americans’ privacy, whether senior government officials recognize that fact or not.  

Finally, we have long been concerned about the degree to which this collection has relied on “secret law.”  Senior administration officials have stated on multiple occasions that the Patriot Act’s ‘business records’ authority is “analogous to a grand jury subpoena.”  And multiple senior officials have stated that US intelligence agencies do not collect information or dossiers on “millions of Americans.”  We appreciate the recent statement from the Director of National Intelligence, which declassified certain facts about this collection, including its breadth.  Now that the fact of bulk collection has been declassified, we believe that more information about the scale of the collection, and specifically whether it involves the records of 'millions of Americans' should be declassified as well. The American people must be given the opportunity to evaluate the facts about this program and its broad scope for themselves, so that this debate can begin in earnest.”